Academic Paper Reviewer identifies a manuscript’s field and methodology, then configures a panel: a journal-fit reviewer, three peer reviewers with field-specific expertise, and a fixed devil’s advocate who challenges the core argument.
A separate editorial synthesizer combines the five reports into an editorial decision letter and a structured revision roadmap. Modes include full review, re-review to verify revisions, quick assessment, methodology focus, Socratic guided review and reviewer calibration.
What You Get
- Five role-separated review reports covering fit, method, domain, cross-disciplinary view and counter-arguments
- An editorial decision letter produced by a separate synthesizer
- A structured revision roadmap listing what to change and why
- A re-review that checks whether your revisions address earlier comments
Common Use Cases
- Stress-testing a manuscript before journal submission
- Checking whether a revision answers the reviewers’ comments
- Getting a quick assessment or a methodology-focused critique
- Calibrating reviewer accuracy against known defects
What Makes It Unique
The panel is built for each paper, and the devil’s advocate seat is always present to challenge the central claim and look for logical fallacies. A re-review mode verifies revisions against earlier comments, and a calibration mode measures reviewer accuracy. It treats pasted manuscripts and committee comments as data, and it sits beside the writing and research skills in the same suite.
Under The Hood
The skill loads a long SKILL.md and dispatches reviewer agent files from its agents folder, using reference cards and templates for the reports and decision letter. It reads the manuscript you provide and writes review reports, the decision letter and the roadmap as files in your project. Pasted manuscripts and reviewer text are treated as data, so directives inside them are reported and not followed. The SKILL.md does not describe its own scripts or web calls.