Skip to content
SkillScript-led938 tokens in use

Edge Strategy Reviewer

A deterministic quality gate for strategy drafts: scores eight criteria, returns a PASS, REVISE or REJECT verdict with a confidence score, and flags export eligibility.

7,427 stars on the repository MIT Licensetradermonty/claude-trading-skills · skills/edge-strategy-reviewer

Skill label

measured from its files

What installing Edge Strategy Reviewer costs

67tokens idle
938tokens in use
2,553tokens, up to

Idle is what sits in context while the skill is installed. In use is its instructions, loaded when it runs. Up to adds the files its instructions link. Counts are approximate, made offline with cl100k_base.

Model dependence Script-led

Script-ledMixedModel-led

Most of this skill is scripts, so it behaves much the same whichever model runs it.

This describes the skill's structure, how much of it is scripts. It does not say how well it works. Scripts: scripts/review_strategy_drafts.py.

Touches

shelldetectedwrites filesdetected

Declared tags come from the skill's frontmatter; detected ones from its scripts, its code blocks and the commands it names in inline code. This is detected, not audited.

How it scores

Quality

How well the skill is written, counted from its own files: its frontmatter, its steps, examples, stated output and constraints, its size and whether every file it ships is one it names.How we score it →
Good
  • Frontmatter12/15
  • Structure22/25
  • Examples12/15
  • Output5/15
  • Size15/15
  • Resources6/15

Security

Starts at 100 and loses points for each thing in the skill's files that a reader should look at first.How we score it →
Excellent
  • Runs shell commands−5

    does this on the machine, and the frontmatter does not say so

    SKILL.md, line 58
  • Writes files−8

    does this on the machine, and the frontmatter does not say so

    scripts/review_strategy_drafts.py, line 909

Repository health

Pre-computed score based on development activity, maintenance, community, maturity, and trend momentum.How we score it →
Good
  • Development activity100
  • Maintenance52
  • Community68
  • Maturity36
  • Momentum40

Edge Strategy Reviewer checks the strategy_drafts YAML files produced by edge-strategy-designer before they go to export. A Python script scores each draft on eight weighted criteria: edge plausibility, overfitting risk, sample adequacy, regime dependency, exit calibration, risk concentration, execution realism and invalidation quality.

The result is a verdict with a confidence score and, for REVISE, revision instructions. It reviews research drafts for internal quality and gives no investment advice.

What You Get

  • A review.yaml or review.json with a verdict, confidence score, findings and revision instructions for every draft
  • A summary count of PASS, REVISE and REJECT and of export-eligible drafts
  • An optional Markdown summary
  • A bundled bias checklist you can swap for your own YAML file

Common Use Cases

  • Gating drafts before they are exported to a backtest pipeline
  • Reading the revision instructions for a weak draft
  • Checking a single hand-written draft for overfitting and sample-size problems

What Makes It Unique

The review is deterministic, with fixed weights and thresholds, so the same draft gets the same verdict. Overfitting is scored by filter count tier and by a penalty for precise thresholds, and the bias checklist option adds a research-bias gate that can remove export eligibility.

Under The Hood

The agent runs one local Python script that reads draft YAML files and writes review output files to the directory you choose. It needs Python and PyYAML, uses no API keys, and the skill describes no web calls. The agent runs shell commands and writes files. Reference documents with the scoring rubric and the overfitting checklist load when needed.

Join founders building with open source

Opinionated takes, migration guides, cost-saving tips, and insights from the open source ecosystem.

Subscribe on SubstackJoin 750+ subscribers