News Reaction Failure Analyzer takes a market flagged as crowded long or short, a list of news events that Claude curates through web search, and price history from Financial Modeling Prep. It computes each event’s return and z-score, groups overlapping events into clusters, and applies a drift-significance test to judge whether the market moved against the crowd’s favorable news.
The verdict is fail-closed: too few events, stale detector data, a neutral classification or a missing price source all return INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE. The output describes market behaviour for research and is not investment advice.
What You Get
- A JSON report nrf_SYMBOL_DATE.json with verdict, confidence, aggregate statistics and per-event evidence
- A Markdown report with the evidence table, dropped events with reasons and a proxy caveat when used
- An actual-reaction label such as FAILED_TO_RALLY, FAILED_TO_SELL_OFF, RALLIED or SOLD_OFF
- A handoff JSON block for the contrarian-setup-gate skill
- A documented price source fallback chain from futures symbol to ETF proxy
Common Use Cases
- Checking whether a crowded-long market shrugged off bullish news after a COT crowding flag
- Running a news-failure check on a single symbol with an explicit direction
- Reviewing a verdict’s evidence table to see which events were dropped and why
- Reusing the same test for news-failure checks outside COT, such as post-earnings drift
What Makes It Unique
The method avoids a simple failure-ratio rule. The skill explains that under pure noise most individual events fail to respond by chance, so such a rule would confirm on random data. It requires the market to have moved significantly against the favorable news, with a null false-positive rate verified by simulation and documented limits under strong correlation. Overlapping event windows are clustered, and the CLI always exits cleanly with a stated reason when evidence is missing.
Under The Hood
The skill runs a Python command-line script. It calls the Financial Modeling Prep historical price endpoint with your API key, trying the futures symbol first and an ETF proxy when the data is restricted or empty. Claude uses web search to curate the events file, with a source hierarchy from issuers and official statistics down to wire services, and is told never to invent events or URLs. The script reads the detector report and events file from disk and writes the JSON and Markdown reports to the output folder. Dependencies are listed in a requirements file.